A Guide to Optimal Self-Defense Rounds
As a security guard, choosing the right ammunition is crucial for effective self-defense on duty. With most security guards and law enforcement officers now carrying 9mm handguns, my top recommendations for duty rounds are built on proven performance, reliability, and the ability to meet the rigorous demands of real-world scenarios. Here are the three duty rounds I highly recommend:
1. Federal HST – 147 Grain
Overview:
Federal HST rounds, specifically the 147-grain variant, are my top choice for duty ammunition. Known for outstanding reliability and advanced R&D, the HST delivers superior ballistic performance and consistency. While they also offer a 124-grain +P option, I prefer the 147-grain for its optimal weight and Federal’s legendary commitment to quality and performance. Despite the cost (nearly $2 per round), the HST is well worth the investment.
Why HST Stands Out:
- Barrier Performance: The specially designed hollow point in HST rounds expands consistently, even through heavy barriers like glass and clothing.
- Weight Retention: The bullet holds nearly 100% of its weight through barriers, reducing over-penetration risk.
- High Functionality: Nickel-plated cases and high-performance primers ensure smooth cycling in semi-automatics.
Specifications:
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Grain Weight: 147
- Bullet Style: HST Jacketed Hollow Point
- Muzzle Velocity: 1000 fps
- Package Quantity: 20
- Usage: Self-Defense
The Federal HST’s superior performance in FBI test protocols, expansion reliability, and durable construction make it an excellent choice for security guards.
2. Hornady Critical Duty – 135 Grain
Overview:
The Hornady Critical Duty 135-grain round has a history of strong performance, especially with law enforcement agencies. While Hornady offers a Critical Defense round, I recommend the Critical Duty due to its additional grain weight, which improves terminal ballistics. I personally carried this round for years before switching to Federal HST, and it remains a strong recommendation for guards seeking reliability and performance. Priced at about $1 per round, it’s a more economical option with proven effectiveness.
Critical Duty Evolution:
- Developed for FBI Protocol: Built to pass the FBI’s demanding penetration and barrier tests, this round uses a FlexLock bullet with Hornady’s FlexTip technology to initiate expansion while minimizing clogging.
- FlexLock Bullet: The FlexLock design prevents jacket separation and provides high weight retention, enhancing performance through barriers like sheet metal and auto glass.
- Barrier Blind: The unique bullet design allows expansion and reliability regardless of the material it’s fired through, earning the “barrier blind” moniker.
Specifications:
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Grain Weight: 135
- Bullet Style: FlexLock
- Muzzle Velocity: Approximately 1010 fps
- Package Quantity: 25
- Usage: Law Enforcement and Duty Use
The Hornady Critical Duty’s robust performance and barrier resilience make it a top contender for duty use, particularly for those facing varied threat environments.
3. Speer Gold Dot – 124 Grain
Overview:
The Speer Gold Dot in 124 grain is a highly regarded option, recognized for reliability, dependable expansion, and excellent penetration. The Denver Police Department carried this round for a period, showcasing its suitability for demanding duty use. One advantage of the Speer Gold Dot is its cost-effectiveness; it offers excellent quality for around $40 per box of 50 rounds.
Gold Dot’s Key Features:
- Bonded Core Design: Speer’s Uni-Cor bonding process creates a solid bond between the lead core and jacket, reducing separation and enhancing weight retention.
- Consistent Expansion: The Gold Dot hollow-point design is engineered to expand consistently, even through a variety of barriers.
- Durable Construction: Nickel-plated cases and sealed primers ensure reliability, while the structural-plated core enhances durability.
Specifications:
- Caliber: 9mm Luger
- Grain Weight: 124
- Bullet Style: Gold Dot Hollow Point
- Muzzle Velocity: 1150 fps
- Package Quantity: 50
- Usage: Self-Defense
The Speer Gold Dot offers security guards a dependable, cost-effective option that provides consistent performance across various defensive scenarios.
Final Thoughts
Selecting the right duty ammunition is a significant decision for any security guard. Whether you opt for the Federal HST for its superior reliability, the Hornady Critical Duty for its barrier-blind performance at a dollar per round, or the Speer Gold Dot for its balance of quality and affordability, these rounds provide the performance and reliability needed to ensure safety on the job.
Fair Use Disclaimer
All images used on this website are intended solely for informational, educational, or commentary purposes, and fall under the scope of “fair use” as defined by Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act. These images are used in a transformative manner, either for nonprofit, educational commentary, research, or discussion purposes. We do not claim ownership of these images unless otherwise stated.
