One of the most common questions we hear in class is whether Colorado Revised Statute § 18-1-704.5 applies inside an attached garage. Students often understand how the law works inside the home itself but are unsure how it applies in transitional spaces like garages.
Under Colorado law, an attached garage is generally treated as part of the dwelling. However, that does not mean the use of deadly force is automatically justified. Like all use-of-force cases, the outcome depends on the specific facts and whether the decision would be considered reasonable under the circumstances.
What CRS § 18-1-704.5 Requires
CRS § 18-1-704.5 applies when:
- An intruder unlawfully enters a dwelling;
- The occupant reasonably believes the intruder intends to commit a crime; and
- The occupant reasonably believes the intruder may use physical force against any occupant, no matter how slight.
In garage scenarios, the key legal question is whether entry into the garage qualifies as entry into a dwelling.
Colorado Case Law: Attached Garages Are Treated as Part of the Home
People v. Cushinberry
The most direct authority on this issue is Cushinberry.
In that case, the defendant unlawfully entered an attached garage and committed theft-related conduct. The legal issue was whether entry into the garage counted as entry into a dwelling for burglary purposes.
The Colorado Court of Appeals held that it did. The court focused on:
- Structural integration with the residence
- Physical attachment to the home
- Normal residential use of the space
Because of those factors, entry into the attached garage was treated as entry into the dwelling itself. Although Cushinberry is a burglary case, Colorado courts rely on the same definition of “dwelling” when applying CRS § 18-1-704.5.
The Legal Foundation: People v. Jiminez
The reasoning in Cushinberry builds on Jiminez, where the Colorado Supreme Court clarified that a dwelling is not limited to sleeping areas. Instead, courts look at whether the space is structurally connected to and functionally part of normal residential living.
This broader definition is why attached garages fall within the scope of the statute.
What This Means for Self-Defense Decisions
From a training standpoint, the key takeaway is simple:
Just because CRS § 18-1-704.5 may apply does not mean deadly force is justified.
Investigators and prosecutors will evaluate:
- Whether the entry was unlawful
- Whether a crime was reasonably perceived
- Whether a threat of force existed
- Whether the decision was reasonable under the circumstances
These are fact-driven determinations.
Detached Garages and Outbuildings: Different Legal Standard
Detached garages and other outbuildings are generally not treated as part of a dwelling under Colorado law. This includes detached garages, sheds, workshops, barns, pole barns, detached storage buildings, guest houses, pool houses, detached offices, and similar structures that are not integrated into the home.
These situations are typically analyzed under CRS § 18-1-704, which governs general self-defense.
Under CRS § 18-1-704, deadly force is justified only if a person reasonably believes it is necessary to prevent imminent death or serious bodily injury.
Common Misconception: “Can You Just Attach It?”
No. A detached garage does not become part of the dwelling simply because something physically connects it to the house.
Courts focus on structural and functional integration, not superficial attachment. Temporary connections like boards or walkways would not change the legal analysis.
If deadly force were used, investigators would closely examine whether the structure was actually part of the residence and whether the use of force was reasonable under the circumstances.
Ultimately, every case comes down to a practical question: could you convince a jury of twelve people that your decision was justified?
Training Perspective: Practical Reality
In real-world cases, garage incidents are often closely scrutinized because:
- Lighting conditions are often poor
- Sightlines may be limited
- Intent can be difficult to assess
- Many incidents involve property crime rather than violence
From a training perspective, deadly force in an attached garage should be viewed as a last resort.
Bottom Line
Under Colorado law, an attached garage is generally considered part of the dwelling, and CRS § 18-1-704.5 may apply if all statutory elements are met. However, each case ultimately turns on specific facts, not location alone.
Related Articles & Content:
- Book A Colorado CCW Class
- Sign Up For A Colorado Firearms Safety Course
- Compare Self Defense Insurance
- Hunters Safety Card Vs. CCW Permit In Colorado
- Hunter Safety Card vs. Firearms Safety Course Eligibility Card (Colorado)
- Colorado CCW Course vs. Colorado Firearms Safety Course
- Hypothetical Case Study: What If Alan Colie Had Been Sued?
- Case Study: The Alan Colie Shooting – Legal, But Was It Necessary?
- Non-Dominant-Hand Taser: A Must for Police & Security
- Which States Have a Duty to Retreat Before Using Deadly Force?
- Can You Use a Gun or Deadly Force to Protect a Business?
- Can You Use a Gun or Deadly Force to Stop a Car Theft?
- Portland Cannabis Store Employee Acquitted in Double-Homicide Case After Robbery Attempt
Legal Disclaimer:
This information is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Firearm laws can change, and local, state, federal, tribal, and municipal regulations may vary. Always verify current laws and consult a qualified attorney before carrying a firearm or making legal decisions related to self-defense. Concealed Carry Classes Of Denver LLC assumes no liability for actions taken based on this content.
